The Genesee Hotel Suicide

 On May 7, 1942 Russell Sorgi, a photographer for the Buffalo Courier Express in Buffalo, New York was on his way back to the office from an assignment. Having taken a different route than usual, Sorgi was passed by police cars when he decided to follow them. The cars pulled up to the Genesee Hotel at 530 Main Street where Russell Sorgi noticed a woman “sitting on a ledge outside an eighth-floor window” on the corner of Gennesee and Pearl Street. Sorgi’s recalled, “I snatched my camera from the car and took two quick shots as [the woman] seemed to hesitate… As quickly as possible I shoved the exposed film into the case and reached for a fresh holder. I no sooner had pulled the slide out and got set for another shot than she waved to the crowd below and pushed herself into space. Screams and shouts burst from the horrified onlookers as her body plummeted toward the street. I took a firm grip on myself, waited until the woman passed the second or third story, and then shot.”. The woman who committed suicide from jumping out the eighth-story window that day was thirty-five year old Mary Miller.

The body of Mary Miller, surrounded by investigators. "She waved to the crowd below... her body plummeted toward the street.". Photo courtesy of Cultural Ghosts.
The body of Mary Miller, surrounded by investigators. “She waved to the crowd below… her body plummeted toward the street.”. Photo courtesy of Cultural Ghosts.

Ms. Miller checked into the hotel under the name “M. Miller” and claimed she was from Chicago. She immediately went into the hotel’s communal women’s restroom, locked the door, and stepped out onto the ledge through the window. Mary Miller was a resident of Buffalo who lived with her sister and had checked into the Genesee Hotel after telling her sister she was traveling to Indiana to visit relatives. Although there is not much information on Mary Miller available, what is known is that her sister was absolutely shocked by Mary’s suicide. The photo, which was titled “The Despondent Divorcee”, has no basis in fact as Mary Miller was not, nor was she ever, married. What makes her case so disturbing is that there is no known motive behind the suicide, no note was ever discovered and she waved to the crowd immediately before ending her life.

Postcard of the Genesee Hotel showing the window from which Mary Miller jumped. Photo courtesy Cultural Ghosts.
Postcard of the Genesee Hotel showing the window from which Mary Miller jumped. Photo courtesy of Cultural Ghosts.

In addition to The Buffalo Courier Express, the photo was published the next day in the May 8, 1942 edition of the New York Times and later, LIFE magazine. In the photo, a police woman can be seen entering the hotel in what was most likely an attempt to reach Mary Miller before she could kill herself; Perhaps seeing the officer enter the building prompted Mary to jump when she did, before she could be deterred. The photo is not only intriguing due to the suicide in progress captured; In 1942 most men were fighting in World War II and women had only just begun to join the workforce. IMG_7417The police woman seen running inside the Genessee Hotel was most likely one of the first woman to work in law enforcement in Buffalo. Two men in the coffee shop, seemingly unaware of the panic occurring on the street outside are seen next to a World War II propaganda sign displayed in the window which reads, “Give till it hurts Hitler”.

 The sign hanging from the side of the building advertises room rates at the Genese Hotel as “$1.00 and up” per night (but you have to share a bathroom, of course) and sandwiches at the coffee shop downstairs only cost customers 10 cents in 1942. The Genesee Hotel was erected in 1882, but this historic building has since been demolished.

Genessee Hotel in 1978, abandoned and boarded up for demolition.
Genesee Hotel in 1978, abandoned and boarded up for demolition. Photo courtesy of Cultural Ghosts.

The famous photo, generally referred to as “The Despondent Divorcee” but more correctly referred to as “The Genesee Hotel Suicide” was used in a psychological study. It was found that 96% of participants in the study did not notice Mary Miller falling to her death upon first examination of the photo.

Former site of the Genesee Hotel as it appears today. Photos courtesy of Cultural Ghosts.


Check out the NEW BOOK by The Post-Mortem Post’s Head Writer ‘Horrible History: Mass Suicides’ AVAILABLE NOW on Amazon Kindle!

Follow us on Twitter @PostMortem_post and Like The Post-Mortem Post on Facebook
Photos courtesy Cultural Ghosts
From the same demented mind that brought you The Post-Mortem Post: FREAK
If you enjoyed this article, you might also like The Most Beautiful Suicide, Possible Relatives: Tina Enghoff Photographs Homes of the Recently DeceasedPhotographer Captures Couple’s Jump into Yangtze River, Scared to Death: An April Fool’s Day Fatality, Last Photo of Mother & Child Taken Aboard Doomed Malaysia Airline Flight, Karl Wallenda’s Fatal Tightrope Fall, Herb Baumeister and the Horrors of Fox Hollow, John Wilkes Booth’s Disturbing Artwork, Turbine Inferno, Pascualita: How Much is that Corpse Bride in the Window? and The Anguished Man: Painted in Artist’s Blood Before Suicide

Liked it? Take a second to support rehadlock on Patreon!

9 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Life Before Death: Overcoming the Fear of Death Through Postmortem Photography | The Post-Mortem Post
  2. Thich Quang Duc: Monk on Fire  | The Post-Mortem Post
  3. Exciting Updates Coming to The Post-Mortem Post! | The Post-Mortem Post
  4. Chilling Photo Delivered to Parents One Year After Their Children Go Missing  | The Post-Mortem Post
  5. Fire Escape Collapse | The Post-Mortem Post
  6. 31 Terrifying Vintage Halloween Costumes  | The Post-Mortem Post
  7. Astounding Photo of Suicide Victim Captured  | The Post-Mortem Post
  8. Away | brucelarochelle
  9. 60 Vintage Crime Scene Photos Shot with an Overhead Tripod – The Post-Mortem Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.